What Really Sets Your Auto Insurance Rate, and the Parts You Can Change
Car insurance pricing can feel like a black box. In reality, insurers look at a fairly consistent set of factors. Some you can't change. Several you can, and comparing quotes is one of the most direct.
What you can and can't control
Things you can influence
- Coverage limits and deductibles
- Which vehicle you insure
- Annual mileage
- Discounts you qualify for
- Which insurer you choose
Things that change slowly
- Driving record
- Claims history
- Where you live
- Years of driving experience
- Insurance history
Six levers worth reviewing
Your deductibleRaising it usually lowers your premium. Choose an amount you could comfortably pay after a claim.
Coverage on older carsIf your car's value is low, review whether collision and comprehensive still make financial sense.
MileageWorking from home or driving less? Update your estimated annual mileage, and ask about low-mileage options.
BundlingCombining auto with home, renters, or other policies can unlock a multi-policy discount.
Usage-based programsSome insurers offer telematics programs that price based on how you actually drive.
The company itselfBecause each insurer prices differently, comparing quotes can reveal a better fit for the same coverage.
Change one thing at a time and compare quotes with matching coverage, so you know what actually moved the price.
Factors that vary by state
Rules differ across the country. Some states limit or prohibit the use of credit-based insurance scores, gender, or other factors, and minimum coverage requirements vary widely. Your quotes will reflect your state's rules.
This guide is general information and not insurance advice. Coverage needs depend on your circumstances; review policy documents carefully before buying.
Compare Auto Insurance Options
See options from participating providers for your ZIP code.
- Step 1Answer a few quick questions.
- Step 2Review available options.
- Step 3Compare coverage and price.
- Step 4Choose, with no obligation.
Opens Comparisons.org, a third-party comparison service. Free to use. No obligation to buy.
Quick answers
Why did my rate go up with no claims?
Rates can rise because of broader factors like repair costs, local claim trends, or changes in an insurer's pricing, not only your own record. Comparing shows whether other insurers price you differently.
How often should I compare?
At least once a year, at renewal, or after a major life change such as moving or buying a car.
Does a higher deductible always save money?
It usually lowers the premium, but you'll pay more out of pocket if you file a claim. Pick an amount you can afford.
Is comparing free?
Yes, and there's no obligation to buy.